Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

The Venture 17 Division Of Education





Managing Headache: Too Many Tests, Not Enough Counseling?

Posted on April 20, 2015 at 2:25 PM
Headache is one of the most common pain disorders seen in outpatient practice, and the authors of the current study provide a brief overview of the epidemiology and larger consequences of headache. Nearly everyone experiences headache at some point, and the prevalence of recurrent, severe headaches approaches 25%.

The high prevalence of headache is associated with substantial societal costs. There are approximately 12 million clinician office visits for headache per year in the United States, and headaches are estimated to cost the US economy $31 billion per year. The evaluation of headache accounts for some of this financial cost, but it can also have severe medical consequences. One study estimated that 4000 additional cancers were promoted by the 18 million computed tomography (CT) scans of the head performed in the United States in 2007. Another study found that the majority of all CT imaging of the head and brain were inappropriate, based on current recommendations. Most inappropriate CT imaging was ordered for headache.

The inappropriate use of resources in the management of headache has led to recommendations to reduce the use of brain imaging and physician referral, as well as limited use of opioids and barbiturates in the treatment of headache. But are clinicians following these recommendations? The current study by Mafi and colleagues explores this issue.

Study Synopsis and Perspective

Contrary to practice guidelines, clinicians treating patients with headache are increasingly ordering costly imaging tests and referring patients to other physicians, and they are doing less counseling on lifestyle changes, authors of a new review suggest.

The researchers found an almost doubling of the use of CT and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in a recent 10-year period.

Although given the nature of the study they could not determine which referrals or imaging studies were not appropriate, the trend toward a doubling of these tests is concerning, said lead study author John N. Mafi, MD, fellow, general internal medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts.

"We have no reason to suspect that headache is a disease that epidemiologically or pathophysiologically has changed over the past decade, so this, we think, is inappropriate changes in physician practice patterns."

The study was published online January 8 in the Journal of General Internal Medicine.

Inappropriate Changes?

Researchers used data from the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NAMCS) and the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NHAMCS) from January 1, 1999, to December 31, 2010. Both surveys obtain nationally representative samples of ambulatory patient visits across the United States.

From these surveys, researchers identified ambulatory visits (excluding emergency department visits) with a chief complaint and/or a primary diagnosis of headache. They also included those with secondary complaints and diagnoses of headache but unrelated primary reasons for the visit (eg, hyperlipidemias).

In the group of patient visits with a chief complaint of headache (80.8%), the surveys provide duration or context of symptoms in 5 categories: new onset (<3 months), acute-on-chronic flare-up, chronic routine, routine/preventive, and preoperative or postoperative visit.

Researchers studied 4 types of measures: use of advanced imaging, including CT and MRI; referrals to other physicians; counseling on diet, nutrition, exercise, mental health, and stress management; and use of medications.
The analysis included 9362 visits related to headache, which represented approximately 144 million visits during the study period. Almost 75% of the patients were women, and their mean age remained the same during the study, at approximately 46 years.

The study showed that advanced imaging, including CT or MRI, increased from 6.7% of visits in 1999-2000 to 13.9% in 2009-2010 (P < .001), as did referrals to other physicians, which rose from 6.9% to 13.2% (P = .005).

Although rare, there are "real concerns" about kidney injury due to use of contrast dye and radiation during imaging tests, commented Dr Mafi.

The study showed that during the same study period, counseling for headache prevention declined from 23.5% to 18.5% (P = .041).

But there were also somewhat encouraging results. For example, use of opioids and barbiturates, which are not recommended for headache, remained the same at approximately 18%.

"That's still quite a high number for a discouraged medication, so there's lots of room for improvement," commented Dr. Mafi.

Also, preventive medication for migraine, such as verapamil, amitriptyline, propranolol, and topiramate, nearly doubled — from 8.5% to 15.9% (P = .001). Abortive therapies, such as triptans and ergot alkaloids, rose from 9.8% to 15.4% (P = .022).

Use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and acetaminophen remained stable at roughly 16%.

The trends remained after adjustment for age, gender, race, geographic region, insurance status, symptom duration, urban location, and whether the physician was identified as the primary care practitioner. As well, there were similar trends between visits related to migraine vs nonmigraine headache, although patients with migraine received triptans/ergot alkaloids and preventive therapies more often, and their use of opioid or barbiturates was higher.

Use of CT/MRI rose more rapidly for those with nonmigraine headache, as did referrals to other physicians.

Acute vs Chronic

As for acute vs chronic headache, again the trends were similar. Use of CT/MRI appeared to rise more rapidly among patients with acute symptoms, although this difference did not achieve significance.

In addition, patients with chronic headache had lower adjusted odds of receiving referrals to other physicians (odds ratio [OR], 0.59; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.42 - 0.82) or undergoing advanced imaging (OR, 0.47; 95% CI, 0.35 - 0.63) compared with other presentations. However, there were no significant differences across time as trends in referrals and imaging still nearly doubled for both groups.

Numerous factors are driving these trends, including a growing number of assertive and demanding patients, the authors suggest. "They come in and say 'I need an MRI for my headache' as opposed to 'I have a headache'," said Dr Mafi, adding that MRI and CT are more available now than ever before.

As well, physicians have an incentive to make patients happy because they are increasingly being rated on satisfaction surveys, said Dr Mafi.

There are also financial incentives for physicians to do more testing and concerns about legal liability if tests are not ordered.

Time constraints are another contributing factor. "There is simply not enough time during the visit to counsel" patients on making lifestyle modifications to help treat their headache, said Dr Mafi.

Reversing the trends will require a change in approach to reimbursement that relies less on the physical clinician visit and more on new technologies, said Dr Mafi.

"Rather than lengthen the visit or pay doctors more, I think we need to move away from that 20th-century mindset and really think about reimbursing care across a continuum of time," he said. "We need to think about reimbursing high-quality care at any time, whether it's electronic or through a secure email message between the patient and physician, or an electronic visit or telemedicine visit where patients can contribute to their records online and have the doctor provide feedback."

Appropriateness Unclear

For a comment, Medscape Medical News reached out to Elizabeth Loder, MD, chief, Division of Headache and Pain, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, and immediate past president, American Headache Society (AHS), who headed the AHS "Choosing Wisely" project that looked at opioid prescribing.

The new study was well done, has "some fascinating findings," and is important in light of the fact that headache treatment and management trends are a neglected medical problem, said Dr Loder.

However, she raised several issues about interpretation. For one thing, she pointed out that the NAMCS and NHAMCS do not provide information that would help determine whether imaging studies were appropriately or inappropriately ordered.

"In clinical practice, we see both underuse and overuse of imaging studies. Patients with complex, refractory chronic headache problems frequently have multiple — usually unnecessary — imaging studies. In contrast, it remains common for us to see in a headache clinic patients with worrisome presentations of headache who have not been imaged."

The data suggest that much of the increase in imaging may be due to an increase in acute as opposed to chronic headache, said Dr Loder. "This is exactly the situation where imaging is most likely to be appropriate."

As well, the results show that imaging is more common in patients with nonmigraine headache rather than migraine headache. "Again, this is a situation where imaging may well be appropriate."

Dr Loder stressed that when the AHS formulated its "Choosing Wisely" recommendations, the committee felt that evidence to discourage imaging was strong only for patients with stable headache who met criteria for migraine.

According to the recommendations, imaging in patients without migraine is not necessarily inappropriate.

"The proportion of scan abnormalities is higher in patients with nonmigraine headaches and we did not feel evidence was sufficient to discourage imaging in those cases."

Dr Loder also noted that the increase in imaging and referrals has occurred alongside an "enormous downward pressure" on the time physicians can devote to patient concerns during an office visit. Physicians have to spend more time on paperwork, electronic medical record "meaningful use" requirements, and other things, she said.

"Ordering tests and making referrals are both relatively quick ways to demonstrate concern for a patient's symptoms and maintain patient satisfaction."

She pointed out that although some guidelines or recommendations encourage physicians to counsel about diet, nutrition, and lifestyle, these are based only on expert opinion. "The evidence that this type of counseling actually improves patient outcomes is thin to nonexistent."

She also noted that the "Choosing Wisely" recommendations were developed on the basis of processes that are less rigorous and detailed than those used to create actual guidelines (eg, those developed by the American College of Physicians in 2000), and the two probably should not be confused.

Low Value

"'Choosing Wisely' recommendations are intended to identify practices that often — although not always — represent low-value care and that patients and physicians should discuss and question," said Dr Loder. "That is not the same thing as saying they are always inappropriate."

According to these recommendations, situations exist where the use of opioids and barbiturates may be appropriate, although they should not be first-line treatments in most situations, said Dr Loder. Similarly, the recommendations encourage the use of advanced imaging with MRI rather than CT in nonemergent headache for which imaging was thought to be appropriate.

"I think the authors are overstating the case for limiting imaging studies when they say that there is 'broad agreement' on these issues and characterize these things as 'low-value services.' They are not inherently low value — they are low value only in specific contexts."

Dr Loder found it "very interesting" that among those presenting with headache, women were significantly less likely than men to have imaging studies.

Dr Mafi and Dr Loder have disclosed no relevant financial relationships. Dr Loder is acting director of research at the BMJ but noted that although she is paid for that work, her comments do not necessarily reflect the views of the BMJ, the AHS, or Brigham and Women's Hospital.

J Gen Intern Med. Published online January 8, 2015. Abstract

Study Highlights

  • Researchers used data from visits recorded in the NAMCS and NHAMCS between 1999 and 2010 to evaluate the treatment of patients with headache. These surveys recorded information from 112 primary geographic sites around the United States.

  • All visits in the current study featured a primary diagnosis (80.8% of the sample) or secondary diagnosis (19.2%) of headache. Researchers excluded visits that included warning signs of a potential serious cause of headache, such as fever or neurologic examination findings.

  • Researchers evaluated the application of 4 standards of quality of care:

    • Minimizing the use of advanced imaging, such as CT or MRI
    • Minimizing referrals to other physicians
    • Offering clinician counseling on lifestyle modifications to treat headaches
    • Avoiding the use of opioids and barbiturates in favor of preferred medical treatment

  • The main study outcome was adherence to these best practices across time. Researchers stratified their results based on the diagnosis of migraine vs nonmigraine headache and the duration of symptoms. They considered acute or new-onset headaches as the reference standard for evaluating the application of best practices.

  • Study results were also adjusted to account for age, gender, race/ethnicity, insurance status, whether the treating physician was the patient's primary care provider, and urban vs rural setting.

  • The researchers focused on 9362 office visits for headache. The mean age of the patients was 46 years, and three-quarters were women. More than 70% of patients were white.

  • The majority of visits for headache were for acute or new-onset pain.

  • The application of advanced imaging for headache increased during the study period, from 6.7% of visits in 1999-2000 to 13.9% in 2009-2010. The respective rates of referrals to other physicians were 6.9% and 13.2%.

  • The percentage of visits featuring counseling decreased from 23.5% in 1999-2000 to 18.5% in 2009-2010.

  • Regarding treatment, approximately 16% of patients were treated with acetaminophen or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, with little change during the study period. Triptans and ergot alkaloids were prescribed in 9.8% of patients in 1999-2000 and 15.4% in 2009-2010. Treatment with preventive medications also increased, from 8.5% at the outset of the study to 15.9% in 2009-2010. Approximately 18% of patients received an opioid or barbiturate, with little change during the study period.

  • Patients with migraine headache were more likely to receive opioids or barbiturates compared with patients with nonmigraine headache.

  • However, nonmigraine headache was associated with higher rates of advanced imaging compared with migraine headache.

  • Chronic headache was associated with less imaging and fewer referrals compared with acute headache.

  • Compared with other physicians, primary care physicians were less likely to order advanced imaging and more likely to provide counseling to patients with headache.

  • Female gender was associated with lower rates of referral for imaging, but health insurance status failed to affect any of the study outcomes.

Clinical Implications

  • The prevalence of recurrent, severe headaches approaches 25%. There are approximately 12 million clinician office visits for headache per year in the United States. The inappropriate application of head CT imaging for headache has been implicated in promoting higher rates of cancer. The most common indication for inappropriate CT imaging is headache.

  • The current study by Mafi and colleagues suggests that physicians are actually doing worse across time in offering best practices to patients with headache, particularly regarding patient referrals and counseling. Rates of preventive medications for headache did increase across time in the current study.

Categories: Clinical Update, Education

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply shannon wise
8:46 AM on August 12, 2015 
very resourceful article ..sometimes a good counselling is better than using < a hef="
icines/">pain killers .!
Reply Nifty Future Tips
5:34 AM on August 22, 2015 
The issue is of the fact that weary long spells taking care of our own feature most people suffer In component, we have to moreover take notice of the regularity involving use
Reply Buy Generic Cialis
12:29 PM on March 30, 2016 
Thanks for sharing such a wonderful post.
Reply caverta dropshipping
8:23 AM on April 20, 2016 
thanks for sharing the post. It was really helpful.
Reply Nifty Futures Tips
9:56 AM on June 3, 2016 
This is very common problem for all, the information is very unique and helpful for everyone!!!
Reply topessaywritingservices
9:28 AM on July 14, 2016 
The realistic world need a good support from online writers, this like blog shares will be a great support for them. Make some extra ordinary work from online by consider the top essay writing services provider.
Reply essaysorigin
9:29 AM on July 14, 2016 
The realistic world need a good support from online writers, this like blog shares will be a great support for them. Make some extra ordinary work from online by consider the top essay writing services provider.
Reply yeezy wave runner 700
12:09 AM on August 27, 2021 
I wish to show my passion for your kind-heartedness for people that really need assistance with the subject matter. Your special commitment to passing the message across had been extremely good and has regularly encouraged people like me to achieve their dreams. Your amazing invaluable useful information implies a lot to me and extremely more to my fellow workers. Regards; from everyone of us.
yeezy wave runner 700
Reply kobe byrant shoes
12:10 AM on August 27, 2021 
I wish to express my passion for your kindness for persons who require help with this concept. Your special dedication to getting the message up and down was surprisingly useful and have frequently enabled people just like me to arrive at their objectives. Your amazing warm and friendly tips and hints implies a whole lot a person like me and somewhat more to my office workers. Many thanks; from all of us.
kobe byrant shoes
Reply nike x off white
12:11 AM on August 27, 2021 
I intended to create you that tiny observation to be able to thank you very much again relating to the magnificent knowledge you have documented on this site. This has been quite particularly open-handed of people like you in giving extensively what many individuals would've advertised for an ebook to help with making some money for their own end, specifically considering the fact that you might have done it in case you desired. The advice as well worked to be a great way to be certain that someone else have similar fervor the same as my personal own to grasp good deal more with respect to this problem. Certainly there are many more pleasurable periods in the future for individuals that view your site.
nike x off white
Reply off white hoodie
12:12 AM on August 27, 2021 
I am commenting to let you know of the excellent encounter my friend's child obtained reading through your web page. She came to find a good number of details, not to mention what it is like to possess an excellent coaching mood to get other people smoothly know precisely some extremely tough subject matter. You actually surpassed readers' desires. Thanks for rendering those invaluable, healthy, educational as well as unique tips about your topic to Gloria.
off white hoodie
Reply kyrie 5 spongebob
2:25 AM on August 27, 2021 
I in addition to my guys were found to be reading the excellent suggestions from the blog while before long I had a terrible feeling I never expressed respect to the web blog owner for those tips. All the guys are actually for that reason very interested to study them and have clearly been taking advantage of those things. Thanks for being considerably considerate and also for making a choice on such beneficial areas most people are really eager to know about. Our sincere apologies for not saying thanks to you sooner.
kyrie 5 spongebob
Reply jordan 12
2:26 AM on August 27, 2021 
I am just writing to let you understand of the beneficial encounter our princess enjoyed viewing your web page. She mastered a wide variety of pieces, including what it's like to possess a marvelous teaching style to make certain people smoothly know just exactly several specialized subject areas. You actually surpassed our own expected results. Many thanks for delivering such informative, healthy, edifying as well as cool tips about the topic to Gloria.
jordan 12
Reply curry
2:27 AM on August 27, 2021 
I precisely wished to thank you so much once again. I'm not certain the things that I might have worked on in the absence of the type of hints contributed by you concerning my area of interest. Certainly was a real troublesome condition in my opinion, however , encountering the specialized manner you solved the issue took me to leap for contentment. I am just happy for your information and then pray you really know what a great job you have been undertaking teaching people via your web page. Most probably you've never met any of us.
Reply jordan 1 off white
2:28 AM on August 27, 2021 
I am glad for writing to let you be aware of what a remarkable experience my cousin's girl undergone checking yuor web blog. She noticed lots of issues, with the inclusion of what it's like to possess an excellent giving character to make most people with ease know chosen multifaceted subject matter. You really surpassed our own desires. Thanks for offering these great, dependable, revealing as well as fun tips on your topic to Julie.
jordan 1 off white
Reply curry shoes
2:29 AM on August 27, 2021 
I'm writing to make you know what a magnificent discovery my princess gained studying yuor web blog. She learned such a lot of things, not to mention what it is like to have an excellent coaching character to have many more very easily master several complicated topics. You truly did more than readers' desires. I appreciate you for showing these effective, healthy, explanatory and as well as easy tips about this topic to Julie.
curry shoes
Reply jordan 1 low
2:29 AM on August 27, 2021 
I really wanted to make a brief word in order to appreciate you for all the superb techniques you are giving out on this site. My long internet lookup has at the end of the day been rewarded with sensible facts and techniques to exchange with my family members. I 'd assert that most of us website visitors are definitely blessed to dwell in a superb place with very many marvellous people with helpful basics. I feel truly fortunate to have discovered your web site and look forward to many more brilliant moments reading here. Thanks a lot once again for all the details.
jordan 1 low
Reply supreme outlet
2:30 AM on August 27, 2021 
I would like to point out my love for your generosity giving support to persons that really need assistance with this particular niche. Your personal dedication to getting the message along appears to be extremely useful and has in every case enabled people like me to get to their aims. Your personal invaluable guidelines denotes this much a person like me and even further to my office workers. Thanks a lot; from everyone of us.
supreme outlet
Reply yeezy boost 350 v2
2:15 AM on August 30, 2021 
I am writing to make you be aware of of the really good encounter my friend's girl experienced reading the blog. She realized too many things, which include what it is like to have an awesome helping mindset to make a number of people with no trouble completely grasp specified grueling subject matter. You really did more than people's expected results. Many thanks for presenting those effective, trustworthy, informative and also fun guidance on this topic to Julie.
yeezy boost 350 v2
Reply jordan retro
2:16 AM on August 30, 2021 
I together with my friends happened to be going through the best advice on your web site and then instantly I got an awful feeling I never expressed respect to the website owner for those techniques. The young men are actually consequently very interested to read through all of them and have now without a doubt been taking advantage of those things. Appreciate your turning out to be well helpful and also for considering this sort of awesome things most people are really eager to be informed on. My honest apologies for not expressing appreciation to you earlier.
jordan retro