Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

The Venture 17 Division Of Education





Maintenance of Certification: Doctors Strike Back

Posted on May 16, 2015 at 3:36 PM

Doctors Strike Back

Underlying much of the controversy surrounding Maintenance of Certification (MOC), is the question of how much, or even whether, the process as currently structured actually improves physician performance and/or patient outcomes.
On February 3, 2015, many physicians received a surprising email from Richard Baron, MD, MACP, president and chief executive officer of the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM). Referring to the board’s controversial maintenance of certification (MOC) program, Baron wrote, “ABIM clearly got it wrong. We launched programs that weren’t ready and we didn’t deliver a MOC program that physicians found meaningful…We got it wrong and sincerely apologize. We are sorry. ”

Baron’s email— which went to the approximately 200,000 internists and practitioners of 20 sub-specialties who have obtained their board certifications from the ABIM—followed by a few weeks (and many believe was at least partially in response to) the announcement a new organization, the National Board of Physicians and Surgeons (NBPAS), with the announced goal of giving doctors “an alternative route for continued board certification.” It is led by Paul Teirstein, MD, chief of cardiology at the Scripps Clinic in La Jolla, California, and an outspoken MOC critic.

While the controversy surrounding MOC remains far from settled, it seems clear that critics of the process and of ABIM have scored some significant gains, by forcing ABIM to review or scrap some elements of MOC, and by possibly opening new paths to maintaining certification.

Evolution of MOC requirements

The creation of NBPAS and the ABIM’s apology are but the latest developments in a long-simmering dispute over how doctors should best keep their skills and knowledge up-to-date—and prove that they are doing so. The controversy dates to the 1990s, when the ABIM instituted a policy whereby, beginning in 2000, physicians who certified after 1990 would have to recertify every 10 years. (Until then certification had been life-long.) The change was subsequently adopted by the other 24 boards comprising the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS).

The 10-year maintenance requirement produced some grumbling among doctors, but no organized resistance. That changed at the start of 2014 when ABIM announced that doctors would need to earn accreditation points on a continual basis over the 10 years between taking the recertifying examination. Moreover, doctors who had board certified before 1990 would be listed as “certified, not meeting MOC requirements” on the ABIM’s web site.

For Teirstein and many of the physicians boarded by the ABIM, these latest changes were the final straw. They were further incensed by what they regarded as the excessive growth of the nonprofit ABIM—whose budget exceeded $59 million—and the nearly $29 million spent on salaries, benefits and “other expenses” during the ABIM’s 2014 fiscal year. A few months later Teirstein launched an online petition opposing the MOC requirements that to-date has garnered more than 23,000 signatures, he says.
In addition, he says, “I began getting comments like, ‘it’s great we have all these signatures, but what do we have to show for it? Have they [the ABIM] actually changed anything?’ And they had not.”
The NBPAS alternative

Teirstein’s response was to found the NBPAS, a nonprofit organization with what he describes as “a much less expensive, much simpler approach to life-long learning.” In the news release announcing its formation, the organization says it is “committed to providing certification that ensures physician compliance with national standards and promotes lifelong learning.” Among the requirements for continued certification are that a candidate be previously certified by an ABMS-member board and have completed 50 hours of CME in the past two years.
Teirstein describes NBPAS as a “grass- roots organization,” one that is funded entirely by its members. Membership fees are $85 per year or $169 for two years, and cover all specialties and sub-specialties covered by the ABMS. “Right now we’ve got about a thousand members and we’re making ends meet doing that,” he says. Teirstein is taking no salary.

As of mid-April none of the nation’s hospitals were accepting NBPAS certification as a basis for admitting privileges, but Teirstein notes that the process usually involves approval from numerous boards and committees and thus will take some time. “I’m of the firm belief that the as long as the medical community is willing to stand up and say this is what they want we’ll figure out a way to make it happen, but it won’t be overnight,” he says.

Teirstein and other NBPAS board members say they support the notion of physicians keeping their knowledge and skills up to date, but think CME offers the best method for accomplishing that. Teirstein notes that CME courses must be accredited by the American Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME) to count towards license renewal. “We’ve decided the best compromise is where you can have lifelong learning which doctors don’t consider onerous,” he says. “The doctors can choose which offerings to attend. They’re not going to pay and take time to go to something that’s not relevant.”

‘It’s not good learning’

Harry Sarles, MD, FACG, an NBPAS board member and past president of the American College of Gastroenterology objects to what he calls the “esoterica” on the certification examinations. “It’s not good learning. It’s learning for the test,” he says.

“ABIM should not be allowed to set the bar, make the rules, and then provide all the CME that can only be accepted to meet their rules,” he adds. “I’m answering to my hospital, my state, my patients, the health plans, in terms of my quality being measured and monitored. And now ABIM steps in and says you should be doing something for us too. I felt like I was in the middle of a shakedown.”

“When I took my certification I felt proud and driven to continuously improve myself,,” he says. “But everything ABIM has instituted since then, to my way of thinking, has really been about themselves and not what’s best for physicians.”

Sarles endorses the idea of physicians demonstrating quality and a commitment to ongoing education, but wants to see “multiple pathways” for doing so. “I’m all for competition, because it will make us all better,” he says. “If we only had one kind of car to buy it would probably be a crappy car. Whatever your criteria are, competition is very healthy and I believe in it.”
The ABIM response

ABIM’s February 3 statement, while not directly acknowledging NBPAS, did appear to address some of its complaints and those of others who have been critical of the MOC process. It said that the board will:

  • Suspend the practice assessment, patient voice and patient safety requirements of the MOC program for at least two years,
  • By August, 2015 change the language used to report a diplomate’s MOC status on the ABIM’s website from “meeting MOC requirements” to “participating in “MOC,”
  • Update the internal medicine exam so that it better reflects what practicing physicians are doing,
  • Keep MOC enrollment fees at or below 2014 levels through at least 2017, and
  • Allow internists to use most forms of ACCME-approved CME to demonstrate self-assessment of medical knowledge by the end of 2015.

In addition, according to the statement, “ABIM will work with medical societies and directly with diplomates to seek input regarding the MOC program” via meetings, webinars, forums, and other venues. “We are embarked on a whole new way of doing business and much more engagement with our community,” Baron said in a phone interview with Medical Economics.

As evidence, he cites implementation of “a sub-specialty board structure that involves depth in each of the disciplines in internal medicine,” and that includes physicians in community practice as well as patients and other public stakeholders.

“Those groups have been reaching out to colleagues and members of their societies,” Baron says. “And what we’re hearing is that lots of the activities we had either as board products or expectations maybe are being done by other people in the [healthcare] delivery system better than we’re doing them. And in that case we want to learn more about those and figure out how to give people credit for the work that they’re doing during their day jobs and avoid redundancy and wasting members’ time.”

Responding to the complaint that MOC tests doctors on knowledge and skills they don’t encounter in their practice, Baron says he took the exam a year ago and acknowledges that it included topics he’d not seen in his general internist/geriatrics practice. On the other hand, he says, “I think all of us in practice confront that there’s a difference between what we use every day and what we might need to use some time.”

Baron recalls joining the ABIM’s test-writing committee in the summer of 2001 and being surprised to find the test included a question on anthrax. But several months later it was a board-certified internist in Miami, Florida (Larry Bush, MD) who first identified anthrax as the mysterious substance being sent through the mail that was sickening—and in the case of Bush’s patient, killing—recipients was anthrax.

”That’s a doctor who had a piece of knowledge that he didn’t use every day, but fact that he had it made a huge difference for a patient,” Baron says. (Bush subsequently coauthored an article about the incident in The New England Journal of Medicine.)

Regarding the fees associated with MOC, Baron says, “Nobody likes to write checks, and when I was in practice there were a lot of things I wished I didn’t have to pay for. But I want to acknowledge that it’s really hard for doctors in practice now and every check is a painful check. We are looking at ways to reduce the cost.”
As evidence, he points to the February 3 announcement regarding enrollment fees. “We are taking time to listening to physician feedback about all aspects of our program before announcing any additional changes,” he says.
“We know that doctors need to experience more value in the program, and the areas we pulled back on were those that doctors were in effect saying, ‘I’m not getting much out of this,’” he says.
What do the data show?

Underlying much of the controversy surrounding MOC is the question of how much—or even whether—the process as currently structured actually improves physician performance and/or patient outcomes. A great many internists clearly believe it does not, according to a study published in the January 2015 issue of JAMA Internal Medicine.

The authors assembled a focus group consisting of 50 board-certified primary care and subspecialist internal medicine and family medicine physicians in an academic medical center and community sites. They found that “at present, MOC is perceived by physicians as an inefficient and logistically difficult activity for learning or assessment, often irrelevant to practice, and of little benefit to physicians, patients, or society.”

Data on the effectiveness of certification since the institution of time limitations is sparse, consisting largely of a handful of studies published over the past 15 years in Academic Medicine, the Journal of the American College of Cardiology and JAMA, among others. And while MOC supporters say the studies support MOC’s effectiveness, in a debate earlier this year with Baron and Lois M. Nora, president and chief executive officer of the ABMS, Teirstein maintained that the studies’ results are, at best, ambiguous.

He cited, for example, the results of a 2014 investigation published in JAMA comparing clinical outcomes among patients at four Veterans Administration hospitals treated by internists with time-limited and time-unlimited certifications (i.e. those who were grandfathered out of the ABIM’s 10-year certification requirements and those who were not.) The authors found “no significant differences” between the two groups on 10 primary care performance measures.

“If you say we have data that supports our MOC process, you’d better have the data,” Teirstein said in his interview with Medical Economics. “And if you look at the papers they cite, they’re very unconvincing.”
Baron acknowledges that the evidence in support of MOC “could be stronger,” but also notes “at least one of the studies he (Teirstein) criticized met rigorous methodological standards.”

“I don’t think it’s unusual to have good faith people arguing about whether the evidence shows ‘x’ or ‘y,” Baron says. “Every clinician operates all the time in an environment where the patient didn’t walk out of an article in a journal. You have to navigate between what you know you know and how close the patient before you gets to that.”
Teirstein says NBPAS has no plans to try and link ongoing education and training to quality and patient outcomes. “I just don’t think you can measure this adequately,” he says. “Would randomizing really work? A doctor might be more inspired to do a good job because he wants to prove you don’t have to do this [maintain certification.] It’s just not the kind of thing that lends itself to scientific study.”

Looking ahead, Teirstein envisions the NBPAS playing a watchdog role for the ABMS and its member boards, in addition to providing certification. “We’ll be keeping an eye on things and making sure everyone knows physicians are not just going to take whatever they’re given. We’re going to react and try to make our voices heard.”
 ABIM requirements

  • Possess a valid and unrestricted license to practice medicine and enroll in maintenance of certification (MOC)
  • Earn MOC points by completing some MOC activity every two years and earn 100 points every five years (at least 20 points in medical knowledge). Points earned every two years will also count toward your five-year requirement, and also count toward the milestones for the certifications you are maintaining. Points earned count toward all certifications being maintained.
  • If you are dual-boarded by one or more of the other American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS) member Boards, your self-evaluation requirements will be waived.
  • Pass the MOC exam in your specialty(ies) every 10 years (first exam attempt in each certification area you maintain earns 20 MOC points).
  • Other requirements may apply depending on your specialty and situation. For complete requirements, visit:

Source: American Board of Internal Medicine

NBPAS requirements

  • Candidates must have been previously certified by an American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS) member board.
  • Candidates must have a valid, unrestricted license to practice medicine in at least one US state. Candidates who only hold a license outside of the U.S. must provide evidence of an unrestricted license from a valid non-U.S. licensing body.
  • Candidates must have completed a minimum of 50 hours of continuing medical education (CME) within the past 24 months, provided by a recognized provider of the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME). CME must be related to one or more of the specialties in which the candidate is applying. Re-entry for physicians with lapsed certification requires 100 hours of CME with the past 24 months. Physicians in or within two years of training are exempt.
  • Other requirements may apply depending on your specialty and situation. For complete requirements, visit:

Source: National Board of Physicians and Surgeons

Categories: Clinical Update, Education and Political Action, Medical Law, Medical Opinion

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


8:17 AM on May 6, 2017 
It has introduced many articles on air blogs. That info is given to understood the values and blog updated stories. Every point you should follow for getting many opportunities.
Reply Skycap Financial
8:05 AM on October 24, 2018 
An organization like Skycaps Financial help people that fall into a financial crisis, which are out of their control and can affect their credit badly and help when the door to an individual or organization is closed based on their credit history.
Reply NancyDaigle
9:57 AM on December 11, 2018 
Excellent and useful information, thanks for the list.Busybox My Boy apk Game Tuner
Reply picbear
8:00 AM on January 17, 2020 
I have bookmarked your website because this site contains valuable information in it. I am really happy with articles quality and presentation. Thanks a lot for keeping great stuff. I am very much thankful for this site. Go to site picbear to know top hashtag on instagram.
Reply Cheap essay writing service
9:34 AM on January 21, 2020 
Thanks for another informative blog. Where else could I get that kind of information written in such an ideal way? I've a project that I am just now working on, and I have been on the look out for such information. It is in point of fact a great and helpful piece of info. I'm satisfied that you simply shared this useful info with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.
Reply Buy Dissertation Online UK
5:32 AM on September 3, 2020 
To maintain a healthy lifestyle, you should consult a specialist and have a complete check-up at least every month. Because precaution is always better than cure.
Reply golden goose
8:34 PM on August 23, 2021 
I am also commenting to let you understand what a extraordinary encounter my friend's princess experienced using your web page. She realized plenty of issues, which included what it is like to have a marvelous helping spirit to let other people just comprehend specified complex topics. You truly did more than readers' expected results. Thanks for presenting such helpful, healthy, revealing and as well as unique thoughts on your topic to Evelyn.
golden goose
Reply yeezy 380
8:34 PM on August 23, 2021 
I as well as my guys were found to be looking through the great procedures from your website and then all of a sudden got a terrible feeling I never expressed respect to the web blog owner for those strategies. The young men appeared to be for this reason very interested to learn all of them and now have pretty much been loving those things. I appreciate you for simply being so helpful and for making a choice on variety of smart subjects millions of individuals are really desirous to learn about. My sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to you earlier.
yeezy 380
Reply golden goose sneakers
8:38 PM on August 23, 2021 
Thank you for all of the work on this web site. Betty really loves participating in investigation and it's obvious why. Most of us hear all of the powerful ways you present both interesting and useful secrets on the web site and therefore recommend participation from website visitors on this theme and our own princess is certainly being taught a lot of things. Enjoy the rest of the year. You are always performing a wonderful job.
golden goose sneakers
Reply moncler jacket
11:17 AM on August 25, 2021 
I want to express thanks to this writer for rescuing me from this particular predicament. As a result of surfing throughout the online world and obtaining opinions which were not productive, I was thinking my entire life was well over. Being alive minus the approaches to the issues you have sorted out through your short article is a serious case, as well as the kind which may have in a wrong way affected my career if I hadn't come across your web page. Your actual know-how and kindness in playing with almost everything was very useful. I am not sure what I would have done if I hadn't come across such a solution like this. I'm able to now look ahead to my future. Thanks for your time very much for the high quality and effective guide. I will not hesitate to propose your blog to anyone who needs and wants tips about this subject.
moncler jacket
Reply off white
11:18 AM on August 25, 2021 
I am just writing to make you be aware of of the outstanding experience my cousin's daughter went through studying your web page. She came to find such a lot of things, which include what it is like to possess an incredible helping style to make many others smoothly fully grasp several problematic issues. You actually exceeded our own expected results. Many thanks for coming up with the insightful, trustworthy, explanatory not to mention unique thoughts on this topic to Mary.
off white
Reply hermes birkin
11:18 AM on August 25, 2021 
My spouse and i have been very fortunate Edward could conclude his analysis with the precious recommendations he had through the weblog. It's not at all simplistic just to be making a gift of guides many people have been selling. And we also recognize we now have the website owner to appreciate for that. The illustrations you've made, the straightforward blog navigation, the relationships your site make it easier to promote - it's got all terrific, and it's leading our son and us believe that this idea is pleasurable, which is really fundamental. Thanks for all the pieces!
hermes birkin
Reply golden goose
11:18 AM on August 25, 2021 
I have to show appreciation to the writer just for rescuing me from such a circumstance. Because of exploring throughout the world wide web and obtaining advice which are not beneficial, I assumed my entire life was done. Existing minus the answers to the issues you've fixed through your entire article content is a serious case, as well as the ones which may have negatively damaged my entire career if I had not come across your site. Your own expertise and kindness in handling every item was precious. I am not sure what I would have done if I had not discovered such a step like this. It's possible to at this time look ahead to my future. Thanks a lot so much for the high quality and results-oriented help. I won't be reluctant to endorse the blog to any person who would like guidelines on this problem.
golden goose
Reply paul george
11:19 AM on August 25, 2021 
I must voice my admiration for your generosity for individuals who really want assistance with this important area. Your personal commitment to getting the message all around became exceedingly helpful and have really helped employees much like me to attain their goals. Your personal warm and helpful information can mean so much to me and far more to my office colleagues. Many thanks; from everyone of us.
paul george
Reply curry shoes
11:19 AM on August 25, 2021 
I have to point out my gratitude for your kind-heartedness supporting individuals who really need assistance with the concept. Your very own dedication to getting the message up and down has been extremely important and has truly empowered people much like me to attain their endeavors. Your valuable useful information denotes a whole lot a person like me and far more to my mates. Warm regards; from everyone of us.
curry shoes
Reply birkin bag
11:19 AM on August 25, 2021 
I simply desired to thank you so much once more. I'm not certain the things I would've implemented without those creative concepts discussed by you directly on my topic. Certainly was a real intimidating setting in my view, nevertheless encountering a professional technique you treated the issue forced me to cry over contentment. I'm just happier for this work and in addition have high hopes you are aware of a powerful job that you're putting in instructing the mediocre ones with the aid of your webpage. I am sure you haven't come across all of us.
birkin bag
Reply yeezy 700
11:19 AM on August 25, 2021 
I precisely wanted to appreciate you all over again. I do not know the things I might have sorted out in the absence of the entire information discussed by you over that problem. It seemed to be a very intimidating case in my view, nevertheless encountering the professional tactic you managed that made me to cry for gladness. I'm just happier for the assistance and even expect you are aware of a great job you are always putting in educating many people thru a blog. I'm certain you haven't encountered any of us.
yeezy 700
Reply supreme hoodie
11:19 AM on August 25, 2021 
I and also my guys happened to be reading through the nice points on your site and so unexpectedly I had a terrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to the blog owner for those secrets. My people are already totally joyful to read them and have now sincerely been making the most of them. I appreciate you for getting indeed considerate and also for deciding on some wonderful tips most people are really eager to understand about. Our own honest apologies for not expressing appreciation to sooner.
supreme hoodie
Reply yeezy
11:19 AM on August 25, 2021 
Thanks so much for providing individuals with remarkably wonderful opportunity to read critical reviews from this web site. It's always so useful and as well , jam-packed with fun for me personally and my office colleagues to search the blog on the least three times weekly to see the latest secrets you will have. And definitely, I'm usually impressed with the staggering suggestions you give. Some 3 tips on this page are truly the most efficient we have all ever had.
Reply golden goose outlet
3:18 PM on August 28, 2021 
I want to show some appreciation to the writer for rescuing me from such a trouble. Just after researching throughout the the web and getting things which were not powerful, I was thinking my entire life was done. Living without the approaches to the issues you have solved by way of the website is a serious case, as well as ones which may have in a wrong way damaged my entire career if I hadn't noticed the blog. The knowledge and kindness in controlling all the stuff was excellent. I am not sure what I would've done if I hadn't come upon such a stuff like this. I'm able to now look forward to my future. Thank you so much for this professional and effective guide. I won't hesitate to refer your web site to anyone who should get tips about this matter.
golden goose outlet